Skip to content

Biodiversity Net Gain – or loss?

16th November 2026

Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) is much trumpeted by those who seek to build and claim it can rescue nature. But can it?

What is it?

BNG is a planning and development approach that requires a development project to leave biodiversity in a measurably better state than before it started.

The biodiversity of a site is the diversity of living organisms, including the variety of species and the ecosystems in which they live. It is the plants, nature and other wildlife of a site.

In England, BNG became a mandatory requirement for most new developments under the Environment Act 2021. Developers must deliver at least a 10% net gain in biodiversity compared with the site’s pre-development value. This is the statutory minimum requirement.

Sounds great. What’s the problem?

There are a few!

The 10% BNG net gain is grossly insufficient. This is a tiny percentage and only provides a marginal reduction in the huge losses of biodiversity caused by development.

This 10% net gain calculation is faulty. There is a fundamental problem in how that 10% increase is calculated – it is over-simplified and based on habitat. This is just not the same as a real 10% increase in biodiversity. The BNG increase can provide a standardised way of accounting for habitat changes, but does not measure every species, ecological relationship nor development damage.

Developers can ignore the local biodiversity harms. Incredibly, current national policy allows a developer the option to ignore any local BNG impacts if it is difficult to apply them – if the developer pays for nature compensation measures to be applied elsewhere.

This leads to nature deserts in our green spaces. Developers can effectively destroy biodiversity where they build, so long as they pay a fee to enhance biodiversity elsewhere – this creates ‘nature deserts’ where developments remain. Our local biodiversity is destroyed, whilst distant areas (away from the communities affected) benefit.

Whilst places elsewhere, far from the communities and wildlife that are actually affected by the development, supposedly benefit from enhanced biodiversity measures bought by the developer.

What does CPRE Sussex want to change?

We are calling for BNG measurement and compensations to change.

We want the metric to better reflect biodiversity, rather than simply habitat change. The calculation for BNG needs to be more accurate and meaningful.

We want the minimum statutory requirement to be increased from 10%.

And we want high priority given to localised BNG measures, so that developers must restore biodiversity in the place that they are building. We demand that protection is provided to the maximum level of compensation required to offset the damage caused by a development.